When Should a Restaurant Hire an HR Director?

Does Your Restaurant Group Need an HR Director?

As a restaurant grows, so does the complexity of managing its people. What may have started as an owner or general manager handling hiring, employee questions, and workplace issues can become a significant operational responsibility as the team expands. Add multiple locations, new markets, increasingly complex employment requirements, and a growing leadership team, and the need for dedicated HR support becomes much more apparent.

But that doesn’t necessarily mean every growing restaurant needs to hire a full-time HR Director.

For some restaurant groups, bringing HR leadership in-house is the right next step. For others, outsourcing HR can provide access to experienced professionals across multiple areas of human resources without taking on the cost of another full-time executive. And for organizations with an existing HR team, a hybrid approach may provide the additional expertise and capacity needed to support growth.

So how do you determine which approach is right for your restaurant?

The answer has less to do with reaching a specific employee-count threshold and more to do with the complexity of your business, the demands being placed on your managers, and the level of HR expertise your organization needs.

When Is It Time to Add Dedicated HR Leadership?

There is no universal employee count that suddenly means a restaurant needs an HR Director. A 200-person single-location operation may have very different HR needs from a 200-person restaurant group operating across several states.

Instead, look at what’s happening inside the business.

If general managers and operations leaders are spending a growing amount of their time handling employee relations issues, navigating compliance questions, managing performance concerns, or trying to solve recruiting challenges, that’s an indication that your current HR structure may no longer be sustainable.

The same is true when HR decisions begin to vary from one location to another. As restaurant groups grow, managers often develop their own approaches to hiring, onboarding, performance management, discipline, and employee communication. Without a consistent HR strategy, those differences can create confusion for employees and additional risk for the organization.

Growth can also expose gaps that weren’t noticeable when the company was smaller. A restaurant that once relied on an owner or operations leader to manage HR informally may suddenly need a more structured approach to benefits, payroll, employee relations, compliance, recruiting, training, and retention.

At that point, leadership needs to ask an important question: Who is responsible for HR strategy?

If the answer is “everyone a little bit,” it may be time to establish more dedicated HR leadership.

What Does a Restaurant HR Director Actually Do?

An HR Director’s role goes well beyond handling employee paperwork or answering questions about benefits. For a growing restaurant organization, the position can become an important part of the company’s broader business strategy.

An effective HR Director helps leadership understand how the organization should build, support, and retain its workforce as it grows. That can include workforce planning, organizational design, recruiting strategy, employee development, performance management, and succession planning.

The role also provides a central resource for managers when difficult employee situations arise. Employee complaints, performance concerns, workplace conflicts, investigations, and disciplinary decisions all require thoughtful judgment and consistent processes. Having an experienced HR leader available can help managers navigate these situations while ensuring the organization approaches them appropriately.

Compliance is another major component of the role. Restaurant employers operate in an environment where employment requirements can vary by state and locality, particularly as a business expands into new markets. An HR Director can help establish policies and processes that support compliance while making sure managers understand their responsibilities.

And then there is the day-to-day work of building a better employee experience. Recruiting, onboarding, training, engagement, retention, benefits, and career development all contribute to whether employees stay and whether the organization can continue attracting strong talent.

The challenge is that a restaurant may need all of these capabilities without necessarily needing one person working full-time to provide all of them.

That’s where the decision between hiring internally and outsourcing becomes important.

When Hiring an HR Director Makes Sense

A full-time HR Director may make sense when HR has become a significant, ongoing function of the business and the organization needs dedicated leadership to oversee it.

This may be the case when the restaurant group has a complex workforce, multiple locations, significant employee relations activity, substantial recruiting needs, or an expanding management structure that requires ongoing HR leadership.

An internal HR Director can provide continuity and become deeply embedded in the organization’s culture, leadership team, and long-term people strategy. They can also oversee internal HR staff and coordinate the organization’s broader people operations.

But hiring an HR Director isn’t automatically the best answer simply because the company is growing.

The right structure depends on what the organization actually needs.

Should You Hire an HR Director or Outsource HR?

Hiring a full-time HR Director gives an organization a dedicated internal leader who can become deeply familiar with the company’s culture, leadership team, employees, and operations. For larger or highly complex restaurant groups with substantial day-to-day HR needs, that can be incredibly valuable.

But not every restaurant needs a full-time HR executive.

A growing restaurant group may need strategic HR guidance, employee relations expertise, recruiting support, compliance assistance, manager training, and help developing HR processes, but the volume of work may not justify a full-time senior-level hire. In that situation, outsourcing can give the organization access to those capabilities without requiring it to build the entire function internally.

This can be particularly valuable for restaurant groups in the middle of a growth stage. They may have outgrown an informal approach to HR, but they aren’t yet ready to build a large internal people team. An outsourced HR partner can help establish the structure and processes the business needs while allowing leadership to scale its investment in HR as the organization grows.

There is also a middle ground. A restaurant might have an internal HR manager or coordinator who handles day-to-day responsibilities while partnering with an outside HR firm for strategic support, employee relations, compliance, recruiting, or other specialized needs.

The right question isn’t whether internal HR or outsourced HR is inherently better. It’s whether your HR model matches the needs of your business today and gives you room to grow tomorrow.

Can Outsourcing HR Cost Less Than Hiring an HR Director?

Cost is naturally one of the biggest considerations when evaluating whether to hire an HR Director.

It’s important, however, to look beyond the advertised salary when comparing an internal hire with an outsourced HR partner. The true cost of a full-time employee includes much more than base compensation. Benefits, employer payroll taxes, paid time off, retirement contributions, bonuses, recruiting costs, professional development, technology, and other employment expenses all contribute to the organization’s total investment.

That means a restaurant considering a $120,000 HR Director, for example, isn’t necessarily making a $120,000 investment. The actual cost of employing that person will be higher once the broader employment package is considered.

Outsourcing creates a different cost structure. Rather than paying for one full-time senior HR professional regardless of how much support the organization needs on a given day, a restaurant can work with an external team and access different areas of expertise as those needs arise.

For example, a restaurant group might need significant support with employee relations during one period of growth, followed by recruiting, compliance, manager training, or benefits support at another point in the year. An outsourced HR model can provide access to those capabilities without requiring the business to maintain a full-time executive position for every area of need.

For some restaurant groups, outsourcing HR can be a more cost-effective option, providing access to experienced HR leadership and expertise without the full cost of adding a dedicated HR Director. But when the business needs senior-level HR expertise without a full-time executive workload, outsourcing can be a cost-effective way to build the HR capabilities the organization needs while keeping overhead more flexible.

When Outsourcing HR May Make More Sense

Outsourced HR can be particularly valuable for restaurant groups that have reached a point where HR has become too complex to manage informally, but aren’t ready to build a large internal HR department.

This is often the case during periods of rapid growth. Opening new locations, entering new states, increasing headcount, or expanding the leadership team can create new HR responsibilities faster than an organization can build internal infrastructure.

Outsourcing can also make sense when managers are carrying too much of the HR workload. Restaurant managers already have significant operational responsibilities, and asking them to become experts in employee relations, compliance, performance management, and employment practices can take valuable time away from running the business.

An external HR partner can give those managers a resource to turn to when they encounter difficult situations, while also helping leadership establish consistent processes across locations.

For restaurant groups that are trying to control overhead, outsourcing can also provide flexibility. Instead of immediately adding another executive-level position, the organization can invest in the HR expertise it needs now and expand that support as the business evolves.

Most importantly, outsourcing doesn’t have to be a permanent alternative to building an internal HR department. It can be part of a long-term growth strategy, providing the infrastructure and expertise a company needs while leadership determines what its eventual internal HR organization should look like.

How Do You Know Which HR Model Is Right for Your Restaurant?

The best HR structure is the one that aligns with your organization’s size, complexity, growth plans, and operational needs.

A restaurant with a large workforce, multiple locations, significant day-to-day HR activity, and a need for dedicated internal leadership may benefit from hiring an HR Director.

A growing restaurant group that needs experienced HR support across several areas, but doesn’t have enough ongoing work to justify a full-time executive, may find that outsourcing provides a better balance of expertise, flexibility, and cost.

And for organizations that already have an internal HR team, an outsourced partner can fill gaps in capacity or provide specialized expertise without requiring the company to expand its internal team immediately.

The decision should ultimately come down to one question: What level of HR leadership and expertise does your restaurant need to support its next stage of growth?

Building an HR Function That Can Grow With Your Restaurant

As restaurant businesses grow, their HR needs inevitably become more sophisticated. The informal processes that worked when a company had one location and a small team may not be enough to support a multi-location organization with hundreds of employees.

That doesn’t mean there is one right way to build an HR function. Some restaurants need dedicated internal HR leadership. Others benefit from an outsourced model, while some organizations use a combination of internal and external resources.

What matters is having the right level of expertise and support in place before HR challenges begin limiting the growth of the business.

At Empowered Hospitality, we help restaurant and hospitality businesses build scalable HR strategies that fit their organization and stage of growth. From strategic HR leadership and employee relations to recruiting, compliance, payroll, and workforce development, our team provides the expertise businesses need without forcing them into a one-size-fits-all HR structure.

Not sure whether your restaurant is ready for an HR Director or whether outsourcing HR makes more sense? 

Frequently Asked Questions